Team Detail

  • Basketball - Varsity Boys

    2025 - 2026
    Head Coach: Matthew Hartman

    2025-2026 Boys Basketball 20-6 (10-4)

    Captains: Andrew Bebak ‘26, Drew Bennett ‘26, Justin Benning ‘26 & Tre Paulfrey ‘26

    Notable Victories:
    -  12/3: 59-50 vs Williamsville North at Daemen University, Coaches vs Cancer Showcase
    - 12/28: 57-44 vs U-Prep , Inaugural Jim Kramer Classic Championship
    - 1/31: 65-61 vs Jamestown, Centercourt Classic
    - 2/3: 58-51 vs St. Joe's, Class of '26 final game in Gerard Gymnasium
    - 2/20: 69-51 vs Health Science, WNY's consensus #1 team in front of 900+ sold out crowd
    - 2/25: 49-43 vs Bishop Timon, MMA quarter-final 

    Highlights: 
    - Tre Paulfrey moved into 6th all-time on the scoring list 1,579 points
    - Mitchell Masiello nets 15 points/11 rebound double-double in Jim Kramer Classic Championship 
    - Tre Paulfrey erupted for 40 pts, making (9) 3’s vs Park on Senior Night 
    - Tre Paulfrey nets 24 points/10 rebound double-double, takes home MVP of Centercourt Classic
    - Justin Benning scores 15 points on 5/5 from 3 & Tre Paulfrey scores 30 points in Health Science victory

    Awards:
    All-Catholic 1st Team & Co-Player of the Year: Tre Paulfrey '26
    All-Catholic 2nd Team: Mitchell Masiello ‘26 
    Most Valuable Player: Tre Paulfrey '26
    Most Improved Player: Justin Benning ‘26
    Coaches Award: Andrew Bebak '26 + Matthew Travers '26
    2nd Team All-State & 1st Team All-WNY: Tre Paulfrey   

    Championship History:
    - Monsignor Martin Regular Season Champions: 2007-2008, 2008-2009, 2009-2010
    - Manhattan Cup Championship: 2006-2007, 2009-2010, 2013-2014, 2015-2016
    - Al-Pastor Tournament Champions: 2007-2008, 2008-2009
    - Catholic State Champions: 2009-2010
    - New York State Class A Federation Champions: 2009-2010
    - IPSL Regular Season Champions: 2004-2005
    - IPSL League Tournament Champions: 2004-2005
    - New York State Class C Champions: 1985, 1986, 1990, 1995
    - New York State Class C Finalists: 1987
    - New York State Western Region Class A Champions: 1987

Basketball - Varsity Boys

Away
Scrimmage

Scrimmage

League
Home

Scrimmage

League
Playing Fields - Nichols - Gerard Gymnasium
Neutral

Coaches vs. Cancer

League
vs.
Williamsville North
Win 59-50
Daemen University
Directions and Details
Away
League
vs.
Niagara Falls High School
Win 54-45
Niagara Falls High School
Directions and Details
Away
League
vs.
Cardinal O'Hara High School
Win 78-43
Cardinal O'Hara High School
Directions and Details
Away
League
vs.
Holy Trinity Diocesan High School
Loss 59-75
Holy Trinity Diocesan High School
Directions and Details
Away
Cancelled
League
vs.
St. John the Baptist
Holy Trinity Diocesan High School
Directions and Details
Away
League
vs.
St. Joseph's Collegiate Institute
Loss 73-74
St. Joseph's Collegiate Institute
Directions and Details
Away
League
vs.
Frederick Law Olmsted High School
Win 69-46
Frederick Law Olmsted High School
Directions and Details
Home

Nichols Holiday Tournament

League
vs.
Hutchinson Central Technical High School
Win 101-27
Playing Fields - Nichols - Gerard Gymnasium
Home

Jim Kramer Classic

League
vs.
UPrep
Win 57-44
Playing Fields - Nichols - Gerard Gymnasium
Home
League
vs.
Aquinas Institute
Win 97-45
Playing Fields - Nichols - Gerard Gymnasium
Home
League
vs.
Canisius High School
Loss 47-57
Playing Fields - Nichols - Gerard Gymnasium
Home
League
vs.
Bishop Timon - St. Jude High School
Win 70-63
Playing Fields - Nichols - Gerard Gymnasium
Home
League
vs.
St. Francis High School
Win 72-61
Playing Fields - Nichols - Gerard Gymnasium
Away
League
vs.
St. Mary's of Lancaster
Win 62-48
St. Mary's of Lancaster
Directions and Details
Home
Rescheduled
League
vs.
St. Mary's of Lancaster
Win 75-64
Home
League
vs.
St. Mary's of Lancaster
Win 75-64
Playing Fields - Nichols - Gerard Gymnasium
Home
League
vs.
Cardinal O'Hara High School
Win 69-34
Playing Fields - Nichols - Gerard Gymnasium
Home
League
vs.
South Park High School
Win 86-55
Playing Fields - Nichols - Gerard Gymnasium
Home
League
vs.
Park School
Win 85-47
Playing Fields - Nichols - Gerard Gymnasium
Neutral

Centercourt Classic

League
vs.
Jamestown Senior High School
Win 65-61
St. Joseph's Collegiate Institute
Directions and Details
Home
League
vs.
St. Joseph's Collegiate Institute
Win 58-51
Playing Fields - Nichols - Gerard Gymnasium
Away
League
vs.
Canisius High School
Loss 48-64
Canisius High School
Directions and Details
Away
League
vs.
Bishop Timon - St. Jude High School
Win 66-46
Bishop Timon - St. Jude High School
Directions and Details
Away
League
vs.
St. Francis High School
Loss 61-64
St. Francis High School
Directions and Details
Away
League
vs.
Park School
Win 70-55
Park School
Directions and Details
Away
League
vs.
Health Science Charter
Win 69-51
Villa Maria College
Directions and Details
Neutral

Manhattan Cup Quarter Finals

League
vs.
Bishop Timon - St. Jude High School
Win 49-43
Villa Maria College
Directions and Details
Neutral

Manhattan Cup Semi-Finals

League
vs.
St. Joseph's Collegiate Institute
Loss 48-50
Canisius University Koessler Athletic Center
Directions and Details
Overall Statistics
W L T %
20 6 0 76.9

Address

1250 Amherst Street, Buffalo New York 14216 United States
Phone: (716) 332-6300

About Us

Nichols School is a nationally recognized college preparatory coed independent school with a 130-year history.
© 2022 Nichols School - All rights reserved