Team Detail

  • Basketball - Varsity Boys

    2026 - 2027
    Head Coach: Matthew Hartman

    2025-2026 Boys Basketball 20-6 (10-4)

    Captains: Andrew Bebak ‘26, Drew Bennett ‘26, Justin Benning ‘26 & Tre Paulfrey ‘26

    Notable Victories:
    -  12/3: 59-50 vs Williamsville North at Daemen University, Coaches vs Cancer Showcase
    - 12/28: 57-44 vs U-Prep , Inaugural Jim Kramer Classic Championship
    - 1/31: 65-61 vs Jamestown, Centercourt Classic
    - 2/3: 58-51 vs St. Joe's, Class of '26 final game in Gerard Gymnasium
    - 2/20: 69-51 vs Health Science, WNY's consensus #1 team in front of 900+ sold out crowd
    - 2/25: 49-43 vs Bishop Timon, MMA quarter-final 

    Highlights: 
    - Tre Paulfrey moved into 6th all-time on the scoring list 1,579 points
    - Mitchell Masiello nets 15 points/11 rebound double-double in Jim Kramer Classic Championship 
    - Tre Paulfrey erupted for 40 pts, making (9) 3’s vs Park on Senior Night 
    - Tre Paulfrey nets 24 points/10 rebound double-double, takes home MVP of Centercourt Classic
    - Justin Benning scores 15 points on 5/5 from 3 & Tre Paulfrey scores 30 points in Health Science victory

    Awards:

    - All-Catholic 1st Team & Co-Player of the Year: Tre Paulfrey '26
    - All-Catholic 2nd Team: Mitchell Masiello ‘26
    - 2nd Team All-State & 1st Team All-WNY: Tre Paulfrey  
    - Most Valuable Player: Tre Paulfrey '26
    - Most Improved Player: Justin Benning ‘26
    - Coaches Award: Andrew Bebak '26 + Matthew Travers '26  

    Championship History:
    - Monsignor Martin Regular Season Champions: 2007-2008, 2008-2009, 2009-2010
    - Manhattan Cup Championship: 2006-2007, 2009-2010, 2013-2014, 2015-2016
    - Al-Pastor Tournament Champions: 2007-2008, 2008-2009
    - Catholic State Champions: 2009-2010
    - New York State Class A Federation Champions: 2009-2010
    - IPSL Regular Season Champions: 2004-2005
    - IPSL League Tournament Champions: 2004-2005
    - New York State Class C Champions: 1985, 1986, 1990, 1995
    - New York State Class C Finalists: 1987
    - New York State Western Region Class A Champions: 1987
Overall Statistics
W L T %
0

About Us

Nichols School is a nationally recognized college preparatory coed independent school with a 130-year history.